I guess I have never had any problems with mine other than the trailer hopping around on the gravel roads. I used to put in alot of miles on the interstate and most of the boat trailers I seen sitting on the side of the road had 12" tires, it was not the tires that were giving out but it was the bearings. I have seen fires started and wheels come off, could be they were not taking care of them as far as keeping them greased and such, its just a personal thing for me, 13 inch tires are pretty cheap also. My boat trailer has 14" tires and have never had any problems yet, but the boat is pretty light too. I guess it depends how you are going to use them, if you are going to go over 75mph, I would not use a 12" tire for sure, just my opinion......you know what they say about opinions tho.

Kilroy